Woohoo I finished the book!! It was a good book overall :)
I don't think Arthur really had a choice when he prosecuted Lancelot and Guenever. He was always promoting justice, fairness, equality, etc. and he had laws to protect these things and to do what was right. If he had ignored it then he wouldn't be following his promotion of what was right and then people might have lost respect for him and then the kingdom would have gone back to what it was before his rule. So even though it hurt him to prosecute the two people he loved the most, he had to do it. I felt bad for the three of them because it was such a mess, but I understand why it had to happen.
I think the ultimate cause of Camelot is...well it kind of started at the beginning, when Mordred was born. Mordred was part of the Orkney faction, but he was also Arthur's son and Arthur made a lot of mistakes or had to do things he didn't want to do because of Mordred. Trying to kill him was a big mistake, but he tried to make up for it by being a little more of a father. Mordred had hatred towards Arthur and played Arthur's feelings. Mordred influenced Agravaine to help him expose Lancelot and Guenever and force Arthur to prosecute them. This also played a part in Gareth's death, and then Gawaine's grudge that Mordred encouraged, then Gawaine's death and Mordred stealing the throne from Arthur when he was away trying to do justice between Lancelot and Gawaine. So I think that Mordred was the ultimate fall of Camelot, from the start.
My final perceptions and opinions of the Orkney faction is that after a while they seemed to change their ways and were a lot nicer, except for Mordred. Mordred was creul and unforgiving. Arthur was a kind old man who only wanted to do what was right, but that sometimes put him in difficult situations. Lancelot was strong and brave until the end, but still merciful. I was glad that he didn't kill Gawaine. Guenever was smart and kind, but she was sometimes a confusing character, I felt bad for her when she was in the difficult situation of Mordred trying to marry her. Those were kind of the main characters of the last part of the book.
The page at the end of the novel, Tom of Warwick, reminded me a lot of Arthur. When Arthur was a boy he wanted to be a great knight and fight in battles. So did this page. Arthur had Merlyn to tell him that he shouldn't only dream about fighting, he could do other great things. Arthur told the page not to fight, to live and do him a great favor by carrying his legend and ideas. Not sure if this answers the question??
T.H. White's purpose behind this book was...partly to make the story better understood by people. Then I think that his purpose was to show that even though Arthur felt defeated at the end of the book, he still faced the challenge and gained more courage. Maybe it was a message of not giving up.
The conclusion is kind of both depressing and hopeful. Depressing because Arthur doesn't think any one will survive the battle and they are all going to die except the page. Hopeful because Arthur still met the challenge, and the page is going to carry the legend of Arthur and spread it around so that Arthur's idea of justice still lives.
I liked the book, but I wish that at the end it said if they really did lose or if Lancelot got Guenever away from Mordred.
Sunday, August 2, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)